7 Comments
User's avatar
Davy Codington, MSPH's avatar

Thank you Dr. Steier and Dr. Galea! As a young public health professional, I appreciate the precedent that you are setting here: to have conversations about public health, especially the difficult ones, with consideration of a variety of perspectives.

Chrissie B.'s avatar

Interesting discussion. I would have liked some more details though. But I get that time was limited... I suppose I should read the book, but I can neither afford to buy books, nor do I have much time to read right now. Too busy running from hospital to hospital to clinic... trying to stay alive.

Jonathan Brown's avatar

I think both of you are still remembering and philosophizing inside an elite bubble. I, an epidemiologist, had a bubble bursting experience early in the pandemic. I was speaking with a guy with a physical working-class job (that he could not do from home), wanting to alert him to the facts about the transmissibility of COVID-19, the importance of masks and isolation, and so on. He really did not want to know. His attitude was, it's not that big a deal. He was not a stupid or an anti-social guy. Why didn't he care? Then it dawned on me that he was fitting his philosophy to his circumstances--AS WE ALL TEND TO DO. He could not avoid exposure. He had to stay employed and feed his children. No point in dwelling on threats he could not eradicate. Better to believe that the work-at-home professionals, who could take care of their children at home when the schools closed, were unrealistic, elitist, wrong about the virus, making rules that helped them but not him, and so on.

And to some extent he was exactly right. We public-health people first made idealistic rules to keep the virus out when it was already in. We then promoted policies that could only work if everybody was like us and could follow the rules, when many weren't, couldn't, or simply wouldn't. Perhaps we did almost the best we could, often heroically, given the ill-designed and underfunded public-health institutions we had to work with. But it was a crisis with no broad-spectrum treatments, it was inevitably a tragedy for many.

I think many of the high-minded recommendations of Dr Galea suffer from the elite perspective and the same excessive idealism that led to mistakes and miscommunication during the early COVID-19 years. Facts and arguments won't change the minds of citizens who, by circumstance, are almost compelled to ignore them. These folks become easy prey for predators and politicians who amplify ignorance and promote resentment.

Seth Finkelstein's avatar

When you say "a physical working-class job", this reminds of one of the paradoxes of masking. It's not much remembered nowadays, but at the very very start of Covid, masking was actually a right-wing idea, mostly promoted by "survivalist" types. In part for that reason, liberals mocked it! And then, very suddenly, almost overnight, the sides switched. This made a strong impression on me, because at the time I was trying to figure out if masking was real (yes, sigh, I was doing-my-own-research, and on the Internet too, forgive me). The most useful practical information I was finding turned out to be on sites which were forums for people (almost all men - probably not all white though, given the job demographics) who did things like construction, home renovation, woodworking, etc. Anyone who worked around lead dust or removing asbestos insulation knew all about masks. And about wearing them effectively, because if not, they often found very directly they'd be coughing badly. However, this knowledge-base never seemed to matter much. It just stayed at the individual forum level. Note this stuff is a physical working-class job, construction especially.

I hate to sound so harsh, but this is something that really convinces me that no, it's not about the supposed snooty, out-of-touch, "elites" (meaning, educated) who don't connect with the Common Man. It's about the relentless right-wing lie-machine which continuously pumps out lies and hatred. That you can't beat a professional liar who has as a full-time job figuring out how to lie most effectively, by using honesty, empathy, and truth. That's wishful thinking, and it leads to blaming-the-victim.

But I have no idea what to do with that insight.

Alfalfa's avatar

This. Well intentioned, knowledgeable honest people keep trying to microanalyze every possible misstep.

The rightwing disinformation machine lies incessantly and effectively.

Jonathan Brown's avatar

Thanks for this. I imagine it’s a dynamic combination of both: victims wanting some lies they can live by, and predators looking for people to lie to.

Cults develop. Not a feedback loop that evidence can interrupt.

I would only add that the world is filled with all sorts of loops this, from dust-devils to tornados. As your recollections illustrate, it’s not only working class people who get sucked in. We all do.

Gad. What a world!

Dorothy Steier's avatar

Excellent points! I’m just curious how Dr. Galea might have changed the way masking was communicated to the public to be more persuasive for individuals to buy into masking - in public, for example…. For those who found it an unnecessary infringrment of their freedoms.